The Occasional Jam No. 30

No. 30 strategy

Getting Better at Cat Pile

4 min read

Cat Pile scores the cats you catch, and the clock decides how many you get to. Spending it well starts with which detail you check first, and that's the hat.

It assumes you know the rules. If you don't, the how-to has them, with an example animation. Every figure below comes from the game's own code: its clock, its scoring, and the dealer that builds each crowd. None of it comes from watching anyone play, so the figures say what the crowds hold, not how players do.

What the score rewards

On a day that catches every cat, the seconds left on the clock include the 4 the last catch adds. A day that runs out of time has none left to count, so it scores its cats and nothing else.

The scoring tiers count only cats, however close the clock got. A miss takes 6 seconds, so on a day that catches every cat, it comes off the end as 60 points.

The clock starts the same every day and every catch adds the same, so the time you get to find a given number of cats is set before the day begins. The last catch's 4 seconds arrive only once it's made, so they can't help you reach it.

The time each scoring tier allows

Jam   4 cats   32 seconds
Cat   6 cats   40 seconds
Wow   8 cats   48 seconds
Read off the game's clock settings. Every miss on the way takes another 6 seconds off.

That's 8 seconds a cat for Jam and 6 for Wow, over crowds that grow from 12 cats to 48. Every catch adds the same 4 seconds whatever the crowd's size, so time is easiest to come by at the start, where the crowds are small and stand still.

Any cat you catch in under 4 seconds leaves the clock higher than it found it.

Where to look first

Make the first detail you check the hat. It comes in four kinds (none, a ball cap, a top hat, or a bow), where every other detail comes in three, so checking it rules out more cats than checking any other single detail.

The crowds, round by round

Round  Cats  Off by  Wrong hat
1      12    3       71%
2      16    3       71%
3      20    2       56%
4      24    2       56%
5      30    2       56%
6      36    1       41%
7      42    1       40%
8      48    1       39%
How the dealer builds each round. Off by is how many details the closest lookalikes get wrong. Wrong hat is the share of lookalikes wearing a different hat from the wanted cat: the ones you can skip on sight.

Every other detail rules out fewer: about 60% of the lookalikes in rounds 1 and 2, 44% in rounds 3 to 5, and 29% from round 6. Even the hat leaves about three cats in five to look over by the end, so the second detail you check matters too.

Make it the ears. When cats overlap, the one lower on the screen is in front, so a cat gets covered from the chin up: its scarf is the first thing to go, and its hat and ears are the last. Run your eye along the tops of the heads, where both of them sit.

How closely to look

Each round deals its closest lookalikes a set number of details from the wanted cat, and none closer. That tells you how much of a cat to look over before you tap it.

  • Rounds 1 and 2: every lookalike is three or more details off, so a cat that matches the poster on any four details is the one.
  • Rounds 3 to 5: every lookalike is two or more details off, so check five.
  • Rounds 6 to 8: some lookalikes are only one detail off, so check all six.

A quick look costs the most in the last rounds. Every lookalike there is one or two details from the wanted cat, so a cat that matches on four or five proves nothing. Skip any one detail, and the crowd very likely holds a lookalike that differs in exactly that one, waiting for your tap.

Round 8 crowds with a lookalike that differs only in its fur
Nearly 9 in 10
The same for the ears, scarf, eyes, or markings, and almost every time for the hat.
The same in round 7
About 3 in 4
Six of its lookalikes are one detail off.
The same in round 6
About half
Four of its lookalikes are one detail off.

Cats in the way

A crowd isn't placed at random. The wanted cat always gets a spot where all six of its details show, and each lookalike a spot where at least one of its differences does. While a crowd stands still, that's a shortcut: a cat with a detail you can't make out isn't the one, so move on.

That holds in rounds 1 and 2, which stand still, and as each later round begins. Once the cats move, they pass over each other, so a detail can be covered for a moment. If a cat you're checking slips behind another, wait for it to come back out before you tap.

When you do tap, aim for the middle of the face. Where two cats overlap, the tap goes to the one in front, and a tap at the very edge of a cat can land on the cat behind it.

When the cats move

From round 3 the cats won't sit still, and the rounds take turns. In one, rows of cats glide sideways, each row the opposite way to the one beside it, and a cat that slides off one side comes back in on the other, in the same row. In the next, every cat bounces around on its own. Each moving round is a little faster than the last.

The way to look stays the same. Find the poster's hat first, then check as many details as the round asks for. A miss grays its cat out even as it moves, so every gray cat is one less to follow, and a cat that glides off the edge hasn't left its row.

Reading your rounds

Under your result, Your rounds lists the day: each round's wanted cat and how long it took. A round with a miss also shows the cat you tapped and how it differed, as in "Tapped: ball cap", and the round the clock ran out on shows its closest lookalike the same way.

Read those lines for a pattern. If the same detail keeps turning up, that's the one your eye skips, so check it sooner. Your Track record keeps the long view: how many cats you usually catch, the days you caught every cat on the first tap, and your misses. A missed day in the archive is a good place to practice the detail you skip.

One note about the scoring tiers. The cuts for Jam, Cat, and Wow were set by hand, before there was real play to tune them against. If one feels wrong, that's my number and not your play.

Sources

  1. Cat Pile's scoring code The points for each cat and for each second left on a day that catches every cat, and the scoring tiers cut by cats reached, read from it when this page is built.
  2. Cat Pile's clock settings The start, what a catch adds, what a miss takes, and the most the clock holds, read from the game's registry when this page is built. The time each scoring tier allows is the start plus one catch for every cat before the last.
  3. The dealer that builds each day's crowds Each round's crowd size, how many lookalikes sit closest to the wanted cat, and how far off they are. The rest of a crowd is filled from cats one detail further out.
  4. A simulated deal Each round's crowd dealt many thousands of times by that same dealer, from random seeds rather than dates, so no real day was built or read. Its shares agree with an exact count over all 972 cats to within 1%.
  5. The board's placement and movement code Where the wanted cat and each lookalike may be placed, which cat is drawn in front where two overlap, and how the cats move from round 3.
  6. Visual search, Wikipedia Why an item that shares features with the items around it takes longer to find in a bigger crowd, and how attention is steered toward items that share one of its features.