The Occasional Jam No. 22

No. 22 strategy

Getting Better at FizzBuzz

6 min read

FizzBuzz asks the same question ten times: which of the day's two rules does this thing pass? Get it right first, then get it quick, because a miss costs more than speed can ever win back.

It assumes you know the rules. If you don't, the how-to has them, with an example animation. The points below are read from the game's own scorer, and the counts of misreadings come from real published days, run back through the game's rules.

What the score rewards

A right call inside the bonus window
150
A right call with the bonus gone
100
A wrong call, at any speed
0

So on any one thing, the worst a slow right call can cost you is the 50-point bonus, while a miss costs the bonus and the 100 under it. Being right is worth twice what speed can ever add.

The higher scoring tiers want both halves, nearly every call right and most of them quick, and no amount of speed buys back a miss, because the bonus on any other thing tops out at 50.

Before the clock starts

Nothing is timed until you tap I've read the rules. After Start, the board lays itself out with the day's two rules showing, and then it waits. That pause is the only free time in the round, so spend it before you've seen a single thing.

The same screen also says what all ten will be, as in "Ten clocks, like", and shows three samples of it. They're picked to show the ways things of that kind differ, and none of them is one of your ten. Call each sample in your head against the two rules before you start, and you'll be warm on the exact questions the day is about to ask.

Then settle where each rule draws its line, which means asking what sits right on it. If Buzz is "a shape with more than four straight sides", decide now that a square is out, because it has exactly four. If Fizz is "before six o'clock", decide now where twelve falls. The section on rule lines below has more of these, counted.

Two questions, every time

Every call is two yes-or-no questions, one for each rule, and the four buttons are the four ways they can come out. Ask them in the same order every time, Fizz and then Buzz, and let the pair of answers pick the key.

Two answers, one key

Fizz yes · Buzz no    Fizz
Fizz no  · Buzz yes   Buzz
Fizz yes · Buzz yes   FizzBuzz
Fizz no  · Buzz no    Neither
The keys sit in this order on the board, left to right, and keys 1 to 4 on a keyboard.

There's no shortcut through one rule. Failing Fizz still leaves Buzz and Neither, and passing it still leaves Fizz and FizzBuzz, so the second question has to be asked on every thing, including the ones where the first answer felt obvious.

The board talks back after every call. A right call shows its points and the seconds it took. A miss names the right answer instead: "It was FizzBuzz". The rules stay the same all round, so a miss is worth stopping on. Work out which rule you misread before you look at the next thing, because the same line can come up again. After the round, "Your ten" under the end card lists every call, and a miss says what you pressed, and which rule you misread when it was only one: "you said FizzBuzz · it doesn't pass Buzz".

Over more days, Track record shows which answers and kinds of thing you miss most, and which way your misses lean: calling a rule the thing doesn't pass, or leaving out one it does.

Rules mean exactly what they say

Most rules are a glance. The hard calls sit right on a rule's line, where a loose reading and an exact one give different answers. Every rule has a line you can find, and the game always reads it the exact way.

To see how often that matters, every thing on a run of real days went back through the game's own rules twice: once as written, and once with a common misreading swapped in, and counted exactly. About one thing in twelve changes its answer under at least one of these six misreadings.

Each misreading's share of the calls the six cost between them. Corners touching cost the most.
Each misreading's share of the calls the six cost between them. Corners touching cost the most.
ItemValue (%)
Corners touching count as joined40%
The hour hand sits on its number20%
A double letter breaks alphabetical order20%
A square has more than four sides10%
Twelve comes after six5%
Quarter past is in the top half5%

Grids first, since they cost the most. "All one joined-up piece" counts squares that share a side. Squares that only touch at a corner are separate pieces. When that rule is in play, it decides about two grids in every five.

Clocks next. The hour hand moves with the minutes, so at 10:55 it has crept almost all the way to the eleven, right under the minute hand. Read the hands where they are. Every angle in a clock rule is a whole number of the face's marks, which sit 30 degrees apart, so count marks rather than judging the angle by eye.

  • A square has exactly four straight sides.
  • Twelve o'clock comes before six.
  • A double letter doesn't break alphabetical order, so beef is in order.
  • At quarter past and quarter to, the minute hand is level, not in the top half.

Cards have a line of their own. A Queen once showed as an even number, and that didn't feel right to me. "An even number" means a number card now, two to ten. An Ace, Jack, Queen, or King has a letter on it, not a number, so it never counts as even.

Four things that sit on a line

  1. Grids

    Fizz
    is the same flipped left to right
    Buzz
    is all one piece, joined by sides, not corners
    The call

    It was Fizz. Squares that meet only at a corner are not joined, so this is three pieces.

  2. Shapes

    Fizz
    is purple
    Buzz
    is a shape with more than four straight sides
    The call

    It was Fizz. A square has exactly four straight sides, and four is not more than four.

  3. Clocks

    Fizz
    is before six o'clock
    Buzz
    is showing more than 150 degrees between the hands
    The call

    It was FizzBuzz. Twelve comes before six on the face. And by 12:35 the hour hand has moved on past the twelve, so the hands are more than five marks apart.

  4. Words

    Fizz
    is spelled in alphabetical order
    Buzz
    is five letters long
    The call

    It was Fizz. B, E, E, F never steps backwards. A double letter keeps a word in order, and only a step back breaks it.

Four calls from real days. Each one turns on reading a rule exactly as it is written.

When to take the extra second

For the first moment a thing is on screen, speed is free. The full bonus holds until a window closes, and only then does it start to drain. Answering faster than the window earns nothing extra, so there's no reason to hurry inside it.

The bonus clock for each kind of thing, read from the scorer.
Kind of thingFull bonus untilGone at
Shapes and cards1.5 s5 s
Grids and dominoes1.95 s6.5 s
Clocks and words2.4 s8 s
Numbers3.3 s11 s

After the window, the bonus drains at a steady rate, about 14 points a second on shapes and cards and about 6 on numbers. A miss costs all 150, so a second is cheap and a wrong answer isn't.

When you're torn, look again. When you're nearly sure, press.

Torn means split between two answers. Guessing between two at full speed averages 75 points, and a sure call with the bonus gone is still 100, so a guess never pays. Nearly sure is the other end. On shapes and cards, one more second of looking costs about 14 points, which only pays if it would fix a wrong answer more than about one time in ten.

The clock, and the end of the round

Each thing is timed on its own, from the moment it appears to the moment you answer. A thing you sit on loses its bonus, and the next one starts fresh with the full window.

Because each thing has its own clock, interruptions are cheap. The clock keeps running if you look away, so a call you leave hanging while you answer the door loses its bonus, but only that call's. It doesn't reach back into the calls you made or forward into the ones to come.

The bonus counts down over each thing and changes color as it drains. I wanted the speed to be felt, because the game is most fun when you're trying to be quick and feeling the rush. With no buzzer, though, the rush never ends a round early, and everyone finishes.

There's no endgame to play for. The tenth call is worth exactly what the first was, and a bad start is one tenth of the day, with the other nine still worth everything.

As for me: I find shapes super easy, and I'd guess most people do. I'm particularly good at words, grids, and dominoes. Numbers trip me up on days when factoring is involved, though I'm decent otherwise. My real weak spot is clocks, and I have bad luck on cards, I swear.

And one note about the scoring tiers. The cuts for Jam, Cat, and Wow were set by hand, before there was real play to tune them against. If one feels wrong, that's my number and not your play.

Sources

  1. The game's own scorer Points per call, the bonus window for each kind of thing, and the drain rate are read from it when this page is built, so they move if it does.
  2. Published FizzBuzz days Each day's ten things run through the game's own rules, as written and then with one misreading swapped in, counting the things whose answer changed. Counted for this guide from the published days, not from anyone's play.